Board logo

Are these edible ?
907 - 24/8/14 at 12:03 PM

Hi All.

A question for the fungi experts. I'm sure we have some, as we seem to have everything else.


I've got about fifty of these come up in my lawn.
Doesn't show up well on the pic but the underside is a light brown.

Edible mushrooms or the devils poison?


Cheers,
Paul G

to eat or not to eat
to eat or not to eat


joneh - 24/8/14 at 12:38 PM

Looks like a common earth ball which is the one responsible for most uk mushroom poisonings!


dave r - 24/8/14 at 12:42 PM

all mushrooms are edible at least once.........................


MikeRJ - 24/8/14 at 02:00 PM

quote:
Originally posted by joneh
Looks like a common earth ball which is the one responsible for most uk mushroom poisonings!


The inside of an earth ball is a blue/black colour and doesn't have the pink/brown gills shown in 907's pic so I am pretty certain it's not an earth ball.

Pretty sure they are a member of the Agaricus family, which includes both edible and poisonous mushrooms. Identifying White Mushrooms is a handy guide.

[Edited on 24/8/14 by MikeRJ]


joneh - 24/8/14 at 02:06 PM

quote:
Originally posted by MikeRJ
quote:
Originally posted by joneh
Looks like a common earth ball which is the one responsible for most uk mushroom poisonings!


The inside of an earth ball is a blue/black colour and doesn't have the pink/brown gills shown in 907's pic so I am pretty certain it's not an earth ball.

Pretty sure they are a member of the Agaricus family, which includes both edible and poisonous mushrooms. Identifying White Mushrooms is a handy guide.

[Edited on 24/8/14 by MikeRJ]


Yep, zoomed in on the image. Not an Earth Ball


benchmark51 - 24/8/14 at 05:51 PM

It's not worth a dose of the trots or worse, go up asda and buy some.


02GF74 - 24/8/14 at 06:51 PM

Dont take chances with mushrooms. Some are fatal or can result in serious health problems like liver failure.

You cannot do the edibilty tests that you with other foods - read the survival guides for more info,.

[Edited on 24/8/14 by 02GF74]


twybrow - 24/8/14 at 07:26 PM

To put it into context there are only a handful that will kill you. There are plenty that are not edible because they taste bad. I am no expert, so look but don't eat. I really need to do a course!

In France, any pharmacy will have a resident mushroom expert who will tell you if what you have picked can be eaten - good system imho.

[Edited on 24/8/14 by twybrow]


907 - 25/8/14 at 08:40 AM

Many thanks for all the replies.
I find this a fascinating subject and studied with interest the link from Mike. Cheers.

I don't think I'll try to eat them, although I am off to hospital tomorrow morning anyway,
but as it's for an op I'm "nil by mouth" from tea time today.
It's been a long wait for this so I don't want to jeopardise this and end up at the bottom of the list again.


I've bruised one to see what happens and will photograph another when it gets to full size.


Cheers,
Paul G


David Jenkins - 25/8/14 at 09:13 AM

Paul - all things considered, sampling random fungi is NOT a good idea in your current situation!

Enjoy you're hospital visit ( ) and let me know how you get on.

Cheers,
David


rusty nuts - 25/8/14 at 10:01 AM

Best wishes for tomorrow from Lynn and myself .


907 - 25/8/14 at 07:43 PM

Nothing obvious from the bruise.

The bigger they get the flatter they get, and the pinky brown underside gets darker.
It has a skirt.
No nasty smell.

From Mike's link, possibly Agaric ? = edible ?
Could the colour and pattern on the top be due to exposure to sun & rain ?
Supermarket mushrooms are grown in the dark.

Cheers
Paul G

Description
Description


Description
Description


[Edited on 25/8/14 by 907]